Mariners go high-floor on Day 1 of 2026 MLB Draft
· Yahoo Sports
Day One of the 2026 MLB Draft has come and gone, and the Mariners have gone back to a familiar draft strategy. After a few years of using early picks on high-upside high schoolers like Cole Young, Colt Emerson, and Ryan Sloan, among others, the Mariners took a hard pivot back towards college players, similar to their draft tendencies in the early years of Jerry Dipoto’s tenure. Their first four picks are all college players, three of the four college position players: 3B Ace Reese, OF Jake Brown, RHP Nathan Taylor, and 3B Trevor Lucas (four players, one last name between them).
In a draft that lacked much industry consensus about order outside of the top handful of names, the Mariners’ first-round choice was actually a surprisingly easy one. Mariners Director of Scouting Scott Hunter spoke predraft about the challenges of this particular draft, further complicated by how late the Mariners picked in it, saying that while typically the organization would have a group of three to four names they’d be looking at, this year it was more like a dozen-plus.
Visit saltysenoritaaz.com for more information.
Those names filtered down quickly, however, as the power-hitting third baseman from Mississippi State, Ace Reese, fell down draft boards and directly to the Mariners. Despite his light-tower power, Reese’s draft stock took a hit after his contact rates fell during his draft year, something Hunter and Reese attributed to a combination of injury – Reese fought through a foot injury to begin the season – and a coaching change at Mississippi State where the hitting philosophy didn’t resonate as much with Reese.
Predraft, Hunter noted the strength of the Mariners’ system remains in their young core up the middle, even if that core has graduated to the big leagues, and the desire to accent that with outfielders, especially seasoned college outfielders who could move quickly. Despite an early run on college hitters, the Mariners were able to find exactly that college outfielder in the second round with LSU’s Jake Brown, who was one-time roommates with current Mariners prospect Kade Anderson. Brown inherited a leadership role when Anderson departed and oversaw the clubhouse during a time of some cultural upheaval. In addition to Anderson’s strong recommendation of his former teammate, Brown also impressed the Mariners at the MLB Draft Combine with his speed – they see a potential center fielder in him – as well as the power potential in his bat.
“Kade texted me today saying, hey, you guys are actually pretty smart up there, laugh out loud*” joked Hunter after the pick.
*This is not me sticking to the no chatspeak rule on the site, Hunter actually said “laugh out loud”
The Mariners went back to familiar ground in the third round, taking RHP Nathan Taylor from the University of Cincinnati. Taylor is a slider-heavy pitcher who Hunter says the Mariners pitching development is excited to get their hands on.
“Our PD group felt like there was a dial turn or two that we can get even more out of what he’s doing right now. And obviously, over the last 10 years, we gravitate to guys who do things like that, that command the strike zone….that have good deliveries, they’re physical, and our PD guys and our scouts line up and say, this is a guy we can help and fits in our program, that’s an easy pick for me, and it sounds like Nate was pretty excited about it as well.”
Day One ended with the Mariners taking Trevor Lucas out of UNC Wilmington. For all of you bemoaning the loss of Ben Williamson, may I introduce you to Ben Williamson Lite? A third baseman by trade, the Mariners believe Lucas has the potential to move all over the diamond, but definitely the ability to stick at the hot corner in an organization that’s thin on those types. But the Mariners are also bullish that they can pull some more power out of the contact-forward infielder.
“Talking to our PD group, they believe they can add a little more bat speed and a little more impact just by some of the programs we will put him through. So…you have to take chances on certain guys, but the underlying foundation of controlling the zone, playing good defense, being versatile – especially in this year’s draft – those guys were at a premium right now.”
The Mariners paid a premium, as well – per MLB’s Daniel Kramer, all but one of the picks are signing for slot value, with only Lucas saving them about $450K to use tomorrow. Don’t expect that to necessarily unlock the floodgates for high school players, though: post-draft, Hunter described day one as “interesting”, which we all recognize as the filler word it is.
“Now we go back in that room and re-rack for Day Two, because it’s a little thin right now, so we’re gonna have to get creative.”
As for why the Mariners passed up on prep hitters early, Hunter said the organization’s assessment of the high school class this year was that it wasn’t as deep as in years past, and the depth there was concentrated in the pitching ranks – one of the draft’s riskiest demographics. He said they had a “handful” of prep pitchers and “two to three” prep bats identified, but between their self-imposed limitations and the limitations of their bonus pool, one of the smallest in the draft, they just couldn’t make anything work, even though they tried to be aggressive in a couple of spots.
“It’s like Jerry told me when I first took this job,” said Hunter. “Every draft you just think of like it’s a 3-1 vount. If it’s there, swing. If it’s not, don’t. And we stayed the course with that. When the guys we thought we would maybe dive into a little bit and look for a little extra money weren’t there, we didn’t chase it, and we wound up making some good decisions…we stayed the course.”